Skip to content
Probably Stolen Wiki
Powered by Pagefind
English
Advertisement
Probably Stolen guides

After-sale complaints: refunds, toxic mixtures and reputation

Handle complaints after chemical sales: who can return, when notes appear, how refunds and compensation are calculated, and which crime records remain.

11/19/2026
1.0

Version history

  1. 1.0 Main guide

    Ghostwater threat-note handling

Probably Stolen Wiki Last updated: 11/22/2026 9 min read

Check which sale you are dealing with

Customer inspection on the counter and reactions after a sale use different rules. A false label alone does not create a refund visit.

Sold goods Follow-up to check
Mixed bottled liquids, Phanta Pill, Vial of “Dream Dust” and Nomore products Chemical feedback, based on the actual contents and intended use
Falsely labelled water Separate false-water and dangerous-water crime counters
Fake cigarettes or defective Immunivax Injector Immediate inspection and the item’s own rules; no generic chemical-refund visit
Incorrect ammunition in a box Separate ammunition tracking and possible threat note

Use buyer inspection for who can expose a label before payment. Use happy water for mixing and portioning bottles.

When customers react

The next normal opening of the shutter processes the preceding sold stock and adds feedback customers to that day’s queue. A reaction can arrive as a note, a visiting complainant or a returning buyer.

Chemical feedback requires a product with a chemical purpose and a personal-use customer who can return. Tourists are excluded. Merchant, Shady Merchant, Street Dealer, Pharmacist, Water Stockpiler, Lower-Level Doctor, Clinic Nurse, Hospital Procurement and the wounded Officer Lun are configured as non-personal purchasers for this system. Their inspection, crime and story rules still apply.

The game groups eligible sales by customer type. It takes the item with the highest positive feedback score L as the main item. Each positive-score item rolls min(8 × L, 100)% once; any success creates one reaction for the group. One L4 item gives 32%; two give 53.76%. A qualifying main item for the ordinary barter addict always produces feedback.

For an ordinary negative reaction, the result is 50% note and 50% visit. This split happens after feedback selection. A lethal non-poison product forces a note. A good reaction can create a customer seeking the original item again.

Inspect dose, purpose and purity before selling

Use Composition Spectrometer on each final sale bottle or product. The Retired Chemist can stock it; it scans owned or unowned chemical goods, so you can check ingredients before purchase too.

Effects use the total ingredient amount in each item. Adding clean water to the same bottle preserves that amount; splitting the mixture changes the amount in each portion.

Effect Game threshold
Toxic Toxicity T ≥750
Lethal T ≥1000
Euphoria level q E <750: 0; ≥750 / 1000 / 1600 / 2200: 1 / 2 / 3 / 4
Effective contraceptive amount At least 50µL of the contraceptive component

Calculate T and E by summing each actual component’s integer µL × its toxicity or euphoria coefficient. Phanta contributes 2 toxicity and 10 euphoria per µL; Nightmare Extract contributes 4 toxicity and 0.25 euphoria. A pill’s impurity changes its actual ingredient amount.

The chemical purity tiers are 0 / 30 / 45 / 60 / 80 / 90 / 99%. Label the real tier, then check the intended effect. A correct purity label does not repair a weak narcotic, an ineffective contraceptive or excessive toxicity.

Calculate the feedback score

For a non-poison product, add the applicable scores below. Let Δ be the claimed chemical grade minus the real grade; an exposed label uses the real grade. Let b be 2 below 30% purity, 1 from 30% to below 45%, otherwise 0. Both Δ and b apply only to chemical products; b also excludes narcotics.

Condition Score
750≤T<1000 / T≥1000 4 / 5
Unintended effective contraception or ineffective intended contraception 2
Non-narcotic with E≥750 / narcotic with E<750 2 / 4
Final term max(g(q), Δ+b), with g(0/1/2/3/4)=0/1/2/5/6

For intended poison, use only 2 points if T<1000 and another 2 if T<750. L0 creates no ordinary feedback. The score selects a reaction; the result table below determines its dialogue and reputation.

Read the outcome and choose what to pay

Negative reaction Base reputation r and handling
Non-poison product, 750 ≤ T <1000 −7; refund plus compensation
Non-poison product, T ≥1000 −17; compulsory note, no payment choice
Intended poison that is not lethal Starts at −2; refund plus compensation
Ineffective contraceptive Additional −2; refund plus compensation
Narcotic with euphoria level 0 / 1 Additional −2 / −1; refund plus compensation
Medical product below 45% purity Additional −3; refund only
Unintended contraceptive effect Additional −1; refund only
Claimed chemical grade 1 / at least 2 tiers above actual Additional −1 / −2; refund only

The non-poison toxicity branches take priority. Other applicable non-toxic faults can add together, starting from −2. A note applies its faction reputation loss immediately; discarding it does not reverse the deduction.

A visiting complainant offers Accept or Refuse. Accept requires the entire amount in cash and ends this complaint without its reputation deduction. Refuse applies the calculated loss. The sold goods are not returned.

For a single item sold for actual price P, processed on game day d:

Claim Amount
Refund only max(P, 25 + min(d,55))
Refund and compensation max(2P, 50 + min(d,55))

A 12-credit sale processed on day 20 therefore costs at least 45 for a refund, or 70 with compensation. By day 55 the two minimums stop at 80 and 105.

Other positive-score sales in the same group add weighted claims. For L1 / L2 / L3 / L4 / L≥5, weight m is 0.1 / 0.25 / 0.5 / 0.75 / 1. Add trunc(sum(other paid price × m)) to the main claim. Refusal’s base reputation is max(r + trunc(sum(r × m)), −20). Truncate each sum toward zero once.

Faction and difficulty modifiers apply after that base. Black Market losses double; Security losses double while its petition effect is active. Easy / Normal / Hard / Challenge multiply loss by 0.5 / 1 / 1.25 / 2.

Compare three measured bottles

Assume water contributes no other effects, the buyer qualifies, there are no additional faults, the sale paid 40 credits and feedback is processed on day 20.

Actual Phanta in one bottle T / E Result
100µL 200 / 1000 L4, 32% feedback; positive returning buyer with budget max(54,120)=120
400µL 800 / 4000 L12, 96% feedback: 48% note, 48% compensation visit, 4% none; claim 80, base reputation −7
500µL 1000 / 5000 L13, compulsory lethal note, base reputation −17

These are component amounts, not whole-pill recipes. A returning buyer seeks the original item ID; if it was a liquid container, Water also qualifies. Check the new item, demand and budget before selling. This customer does not generate another positive return through the same chain.

Recognize and handle a Ghostwater threat note

Double-click the Handwritten Note and compare its text below. These six messages all use the same Ghostwater warning. Read it, then close it. It has no reply, payment, deadline or attacker-arrival choice; its endangerment charge was already applied before the note appeared.

Possible note text
Stop selling that bogus water, you are killing us!
We know what you did. Stop the water scam, NOW!
Keep on selling tainted water, and you’ll regret it.
How do you sleep when you are selling Ghostwater as drinking water?
Stop the Ghostwater scam, or we’ll stop you ourselves.
Your fake water is killing us. You’re next.

Selling undiscovered Ghostwater as Basewater, High-Quality Water or Pure Water adds the bottle’s total liquid volume, rounded down to whole mL, at ×1, ×2 or ×4. Tourists skip this tracking. Each shutter opening first subtracts 5; at a remaining total of at least 2500, every complete 500 becomes 20 base endangerment units, the remainder stays, and one note appears. Other inflated water grades use a separate fraud counter.

For example, with no earlier accumulation, 3000mL of Ghostwater labelled Basewater becomes 2995 on opening: 100 base endangerment, remainder 495 and one note. With no further sales, the following opening leaves 490 and adds no new charge or note. Crime-modifying traits can change the base charge.

Stop selling the remaining batch. Use water-quality tests to identify the actual grade, then correct the red label. Treat and retest it before selling it as drinking water. Check existing charges and case-handling options; closing or discarding the paper does not clear them. If the wording differs from all six messages, identify that letter before applying these steps.

Track crime separately and deal with remaining stock

Chemical crime is calculated before feedback selection, including customers who cannot give personal-use feedback. The chemical check skips Black Market and Revolution buyers and goods currently treated as contraband. For other eligible sales, low toxicity can still accumulate fraud or endangerment.

That newly added chemical accumulation converts on a later shutter opening: every 300 converts into the corresponding number of crime units, retaining the remainder. Water mislabelling has its own counters and timing. Paying a complaint does not clear either record; use crime and hiding for the case.

Remaining task Operation
Goods already sold There is no normal recall action. Isolate the unsold batch and scan it.
Same-bottle toxicity remains high Separate portions or remove the responsible component; rescan each final item.
Complaint payment is unavailable Check cash against the full claim, including associated sales.
Note already deducted reputation Read its cause and correct the next batch.
A customer wants another bottle Scan the new portion and check their current buying conditions.

Related Articles

Was this helpful?

Wiki guide

Ask about the game. I search the published guides and link to the pages behind each answer.

AI answers can be wrong. Open the sources to check.

Send feedback

Found an error, have a suggestion, or need help? Tell us here.

Capture this page’s visible area. Preview or remove it before sending.

Page:

Your message and technical details such as your IP address go to our support inbox. Please do not include passwords or payment details.